Share Article:

The Decisions You Don’t Want to Make During a Crisis

A strong incident response plan gives your team the people, priorities, and procedures they need to act quickly when normal business operations are disrupted.

When a serious technology incident hits, the first few minutes can feel deceptively simple. Someone notices a problem, an alert comes through, or an employee reports something unusual. Then the questions begin. Who needs to make the call? Should employees keep working? Do customers need to know? Which systems need attention first?

Those aren’t questions you want your leadership team debating while systems are unavailable or a cybersecurity incident is unfolding. Under pressure, even experienced people can make different assumptions about what needs to happen next. That uncertainty wastes time at exactly the moment when clear decisions matter most.

An effective incident response plan removes as much of that uncertainty as possible. It gives your team a practical framework for responding to disruption, whether the problem is a cyberattack, system failure, data loss, or another event affecting normal business operations.

For Victorian businesses, the goal isn’t to create an enormous technical manual nobody will read. It’s to make sure six important areas have been addressed before your team ever needs to rely on the plan.

Make Accountability Clear Before the Pressure Starts

During normal operations, it’s often easy to work out who should handle an issue. During a significant disruption, responsibilities can become surprisingly unclear.

One executive assumes IT is coordinating the response. IT assumes leadership is handling customer communication. Someone contacts a vendor while another person unknowingly does the same thing. Meanwhile, an important task can be missed because everyone assumes somebody else owns it.

Your incident response plan should clearly establish who makes business decisions, who communicates with employees, who works with technology providers, and who manages communication with customers, vendors, and other stakeholders. These responsibilities don’t need to make the plan complicated. They simply need to remove ambiguity.

When ownership is clear, people can act instead of waiting for instructions. Leadership also maintains better visibility because everyone understands who is responsible for each part of the response.

Put The Right People Within Immediate Reach

Finding a phone number sounds trivial until you’re trying to do it while a critical system is unavailable.

An incident response plan should contain current contact details for the people and organisations your business may need during a disruption. That could include internal leadership, your IT provider, important software vendors, cyber insurance contacts, legal advisers, and key business partners.

The important word is current. A contact list created two years ago isn’t particularly useful if the account manager has changed, an employee has left, or your insurance provider now uses a different incident reporting process.

This information should also be accessible if your usual systems aren’t. If the only copy of your emergency contact list is stored inside a platform you can’t access during an outage, it won’t provide much help. A good plan considers not only what information people need, but how they’ll reach it under less-than-normal circumstances.

Plan How You’ll Communicate When Normal Channels Aren’t Available

One of the easiest assumptions to make is that you’ll simply email everyone if something happens.

But what if email is the problem?

A serious technology incident can take down the very communication tools your team normally relies on. Email, Microsoft Teams, cloud applications, or internal systems may be unavailable or potentially compromised. Without an alternative, communication can quickly become fragmented.

Your response plan should establish how employees will receive instructions if primary channels are unavailable. It should also identify who communicates with customers, vendors, and other external stakeholders, and how those messages will be coordinated.

Clear communication matters because silence creates uncertainty. Employees start making their own assumptions, customers wonder what’s happening, and different people may share conflicting information. Having an agreed communication process helps the business stay composed and credible, even while the underlying problem is still being resolved.

Decide What Comes Back Online First

Not every system in your business is equally important.

Your payroll platform, customer database, email, accounting system, production software, and shared files may all matter, but they don’t necessarily need to be restored in the same order. During a major outage, trying to recover everything simultaneously can slow the process down.

A strong incident response plan identifies the applications and business processes that are genuinely critical to keeping the organisation operating. It should also establish recovery priorities and give leadership a realistic understanding of how much downtime the business can tolerate.

These are business decisions as much as technical ones. IT can explain how systems depend on one another and what recovery involves, but executives need to determine which functions matter most to customers, revenue, employees, and ongoing operations.

Making those decisions in advance gives the recovery team a clear target. Instead of asking, “What should we fix first?” during the incident, they can focus immediately on restoring what matters most.

Give Your Team A Process They Can Actually Follow

An incident response plan shouldn’t require someone to interpret a complicated document while the business is under pressure.

It should provide a clear sequence of actions covering the initial response, escalation, recovery priorities, and important decision points. People need to understand what happens first, what happens next, and when an issue needs to move to someone with greater authority.

The procedures don’t need to explain every technical detail. In fact, trying to account for every possible scenario can make a plan harder to use. The objective is to provide enough structure that people can implement consistently while still allowing experienced professionals to make decisions based on the situation.

That structure is particularly valuable for employees who haven’t dealt with a major incident before. Instead of relying entirely on memory or instinct, they have a framework to follow when pressure is high.

Test The Plan Before You Have to Trust It

Creating an incident response plan is a good start. Putting it in a folder and forgetting about it isn’t.

Businesses change constantly. Employees leave, new people join, software platforms are replaced, vendors change, and critical processes evolve. A response plan that accurately reflected your business twelve months ago may already contain gaps today.

Regular reviews should confirm contact information, responsibilities, recovery priorities, and procedures are still accurate. Testing is equally important because it reveals problems that aren’t obvious when you’re simply reading the document.

A practical exercise might uncover that an employee doesn’t know their role, an emergency contact is outdated, a backup takes considerably longer to restore than expected, or an important business system was never included in the recovery priorities. Those are valuable discoveries during a test. They’re expensive discoveries during a real incident.

Testing also gives your team experience. The first time people work through the response shouldn’t be while customers are waiting and the business is losing productive time.

Preparation Turns a Crisis Into a Process

No incident response plan can guarantee your business will never experience disruption. That’s not what it’s designed to do.

Its value is in reducing the number of decisions your team has to make from scratch when something does happen. Responsibilities are already assigned. Important contacts are available. Communication procedures are established. Recovery priorities have been agreed upon, and your team has practised what comes next.

That changes the nature of an incident. Instead of a room full of people asking, “What do we do now?”, you have a team working through a plan they already understand.

For business leaders, that’s the real measure of preparedness.

If you’re not confident your current incident response plan answers these questions, it may be time to review it before you’re forced to find the gaps during a real disruption.

A 10-minute discovery call can help you understand what’s already covered, where uncertainty remains, and what should be strengthened so your team is ready to respond when it matters.

The Phishing Email You’re Looking for Doesn’t Exist Anymore

Poor spelling and suspicious-looking messages used to make phishing easier to spot. AI is changing the rules, and businesses need...

Not Every Cyber Threat Has to Break In

Some of the biggest cybersecurity risks already have legitimate access to your systems. Managing insider risk starts with understanding how...

The Recovery Mistakes You Can Fix Before They Cost You

Most recovery failures aren’t caused by a lack of technology. They happen when backups, responsibilities, communication, and recovery plans haven’t...